At 46 years old, Susan is dating online after being divorced three times. With a heart as big as her home state of Texas, Susan gives every man a chance. Her stories are both heartwarming and hard to hear. Her willingness to give her time and attention, as well as her joie-de-vivre and sense of humor have landed her with less than a healthy dating life. Paula gives Susan a dose of reality on how being too nice eases loneliness in the moment, but hurts in the long run to finding and keeping a Mr. Right.